My Father-in-Law called yesterday and said to check the well again. Apparently he had a similar incident with his well where the water from a delivery disapeared, only to reappear a day or two later. I checked it yesterday. Sure enough, there was water! I checked it today and sure enough, there was a ton of water. We've never had something like this happen before but I really don't care. My well works!
The wonderful Father-in-Law came over this morning, fiddled around with the pump and got it primed.
So I'm done whining and monaing and complaining for now.